I’ve been using Google+ for a while now. I was on the beta and I’ve been using it ever since. Here’s a look at why I prefer it to facebook.
I’m not a big fan of Facebook. I’m on it, I use it and it has a couple of nice features. The events function is great. I can’t remember the last time I was in an office, where you couldn’t use email to set up a meeting with people. Letting people do this with their friends and personal contacts is great. Allowing people to set the status from a private party, to a public event, where anyone can show up, is a great way of having new people turn up to your event.
The down side of facebook outweighs the good. I’ll skim over some highlights.
First there is the habit it encourages of not actually staying in touch with people. Instead of picking up the phone or firing off an email saying “Hey, what’s up?” people stalk you. Oh he went on holiday, that looks nice, Oh she broke up with her boyfriend, shame, he seemed nice, etc. This means you have, so-called friends, you haven’t spoken to in years. Sure, there are people you speak to every day and facebook isn’t going to change that, but for the people you’d speak to a few times a year, it’s a different story and a lot is lost through the filter of what we post on facebook.
Next is the privacy thing, others have written very well on why facebook has said: age of privacy is over. So I won’t repeat that here, but I will say that that is complete bull and they only say it so they can make more money. And therein lies the crux of the problem, facebook wants to fool people into sharing more. They do it through propaganda like that and by screwing with their privacy settings.
So when I click through from a comment and find some stranger’s facebook wall shared with me+world, I assume it’s a mistake. Even if there happens to be an interesting post on that wall, there is no way I am going to comment. To me, that would be like wandering down a busy street, walking past a home with an open window, over hearing an interesting conversation and sticking my head through their window to join in.
Compare that with Google+, where every single post has to be assigned a privacy setting. This means that when I see an interesting post from a stranger, I was meant to see it. If comments are enabled, I’m invited to join in the discussion. This has happened to me countless times since I joined Google+ with only one encounter being negative (They turned out to be nuts). So I’ve met people I would never have met before, I’ve had polite disagreements with people, where we’ve exchanged different points of view and I have people in my circles I would never have had the opportunity to interact with, if it wasn’t for Google+.
Additionally, Google+ is very young, with new features in the works. I can’t say how those will impact the service until I see them, but given the approach taken so far, I’m hopeful about what we will see and how it will let strangers become friends, or at least acquaintances.
What do you think?